Tips for When You Know You Need Therapy but Don’t Know How to Open Up (or Fill a Session)
By Owen Allie, Licensed Professional Counselor
Making the decision to start therapy is a significant step, but many people arrive at their first appointment with the same concern:
“I know I need therapy… I just don’t know what to say.”
After more than a decade as a Licensed Professional Counselor—including extensive experience working with individuals recovering from substance use disorders—I’ve heard this countless times. People often worry they’ll sit in silence, say the “wrong” thing, or run out of topics before the hour is over.
The good news is that you don’t have to show up with everything figured out. Therapy isn’t about giving the perfect explanation of your life. It’s a place where we learn to put difficult experiences into words together, at a pace that feels comfortable for you.
Why It’s Normal to Feel Stuck
Many first-time therapy clients experience two common hurdles before they even begin talking.
Fear of Being Judged
It’s common to wonder if your problems are “serious enough” or whether your therapist will think differently of you after hearing your story.
The reality is that therapy isn’t about judging your experiences—it’s about understanding them. Every thought, feeling, and experience provides valuable information that helps guide treatment.
Nervous about Opening Up in Therapy?
Not Knowing Where to Begin
Sometimes the hardest part isn’t talking—it’s deciding which story to tell first.
Should you talk about your childhood?
Your relationship?
Your anxiety?
Work stress?
Family?
Instead of trying to organize your entire life, I often encourage clients to begin with one simple question:
When did something start feeling different?
Think about when you first noticed a change in your:
- Sleep
- Appetite
- Energy
- Motivation
- Concentration
- Relationships
- Performance at work or school
What changed?
What felt “off”?
Does this feeling remind you of another time in your life?
Those questions often become the doorway into deeper conversations.
A Simple Way to Start Every Therapy Session
If you’re unsure how to begin, try this simple framework.
The Highs, Lows, and Meaning Check-In
Start by answering four questions:
One thing that went well this week…
Share one positive experience or small victory.
One thing that was difficult…
Talk about one challenge you’ve faced.
What did it mean to you?
Ask yourself:
- What was I telling myself?
- What emotions came up?
- Why did this affect me so much?
What would you like to work on today?
Finish with one sentence:
“If we accomplish one thing today, I’d like to understand…”
or
“Today I’d like help with…”
This simple structure helps celebrate progress while identifying the areas that need the most attention.
What If You Go Blank During Therapy?
It happens more often than you might think.
Sometimes emotions become overwhelming.
Sometimes your mind simply freezes.
Sometimes you genuinely don’t know what to say next.
That’s okay.
You don’t have to keep the conversation moving by yourself. Part of my role is asking thoughtful questions, helping organize your thoughts, and creating an environment where talking feels easier over time.
Five Conversation Starters You Can Use
If you’re stuck, try saying one of these:
- “I don’t know where to start, but something changed after…”
- “I’m afraid you’ll judge me for this.”
- “Here are the three biggest things that happened this week…”
- “Can you ask me some questions? My mind feels blank.”
- “I’m scared that if I start talking, I won’t be able to stop.”
Believe it or not, simply saying “I’m stuck” is already doing therapy.
You Don’t Have to Fill the Hour
One of the biggest misconceptions about therapy is that clients are responsible for keeping the conversation going.
You aren’t.
A therapy session is structured to help you make meaningful progress without feeling like you’re performing.
Here’s What a Typical Session Looks Like
Opening (5–10 minutes)
We’ll check in about how your week has been, discuss any important updates, and decide what feels most important to focus on.
Working Through the Main Concern (30–35 minutes)
Most of the session is dedicated to exploring the issue that’s bringing you to therapy.
If the conversation naturally drifts, I’ll help guide us back to what matters most while still allowing space for important discoveries along the way.
Wrapping Up (5–10 minutes)
We’ll summarize what we learned, identify practical takeaways, and discuss one small step you can practice before our next session.
Easy Ways to Prepare Before Therapy
You don’t need pages of journal entries.
One to three minutes of reflection can make starting a session much easier.
Consider writing down:
- One thing that felt off this week
- A change you noticed in your sleep, mood, energy, or motivation
- Something that reminded you of the past
- One question you’re hoping to answer
Even a few bullet points can help you remember what felt important.
If You Don’t Know What to Say, Start Here
Sometimes one sentence is enough.
Try one of these:
- “Can we talk about the last time I remember feeling like myself?”
- “I don’t really have a story—I just feel anxious.”
- “I need help finding the words.”
- “Something feels different, and I can’t explain why.”
Those simple statements often lead to meaningful conversations.
Using Numbers Can Help
If words feel difficult, numbers can be a great starting point.
Before your session, rate the following from 0–10:
- Mood
- Anxiety
- Energy
- Stress
- Motivation
These ratings don’t tell the whole story, but they give us a helpful starting point and make it easier to notice progress over time.
Common Fears About Therapy
“What if I cry?”
Then we’ll slow down.
Strong emotions are welcome in therapy.
We can pause, breathe, take a break, or shift the conversation if needed.
There is no expectation that you have to push through overwhelming emotions.
“What if I say the wrong thing?”
There isn’t a wrong thing and what you share is confidential except in certain circumstances.
Everything you share helps us better understand your experiences and determine how to move forward.
“What if I don’t know what’s wrong?”
Many people begin therapy without a clear answer.
Part of our work together is figuring that out.
You don’t need a diagnosis or perfect explanation before asking for help.
A Real-Life Example
One client came into session saying,
“I honestly don’t know what to talk about today.”
We started with highs and lows.
One low was that they had skipped meals throughout the week and felt mentally foggy.
As we explored that further, we discovered the pattern had started after beginning a demanding new job.
That conversation eventually connected to childhood experiences of feeling responsible for everyone else.
Instead of trying to solve everything in one session, we focused on two small goals:
- Setting a daily reminder to eat lunch.
- Taking a two-minute mindfulness break after stressful meetings.
The following week they returned saying,
“The reminders helped… and I realized I’m terrified of disappointing people.”
That became the focus of our next session.
Sometimes the smallest starting point leads to the biggest breakthrough.
A Simple One-Week Practice Plan
If you’re preparing for therapy, try this exercise before your next appointment.
Days 1–2
Write down:
- One high
- One low
- The thought or feeling connected to each
Day 3
Notice one change in your daily functioning.
For example:
“Since changing jobs, my motivation has decreased.”
Day 4
Write one sentence you’d like to discuss.
“I’d like to understand why I keep avoiding difficult conversations.”
Day 5
Practice one small coping strategy.
Ideas include:
- Taking a short walk
- Practicing two minutes of deep breathing
- Setting one healthy boundary
- Writing down one recurring thought
Day 6
Reflect briefly.
- What helped?
- What got in the way?
Day 7
Choose just one next step.
Progress doesn’t require perfection.
Final Thoughts
If you know you need therapy but don’t know how to open up, you’re not alone.
You don’t need the perfect words.
You don’t need to tell your entire life story.
You don’t need to fill every minute of the session.
Start with one sentence.
Start with one feeling.
Start with one question.
If you freeze, simply tell your therapist.
Sometimes the most powerful words you can say are:
“I don’t know where to start.”
From there, we’ll figure it out together.
Ready to Take the First Step?
If you’ve been considering therapy but have been putting it off because you’re worried about what to say, remember that you don’t have to have everything figured out before your first appointment. Therapy is a place to explore your thoughts, gain clarity, and develop practical tools for navigating life’s challenges.
At Dr. Goldberg & Associates, our therapists provide compassionate, evidence-based care for anxiety, depression, trauma, substance use, life transitions, and many other concerns. Whether you’re new to therapy or returning after time away, we’re here to help you take that first step with confidence.
Schedule an appointment today and begin your journey toward healing and personal growth.
Written by:

