Will My Insurance Cover Therapy? What You Need to Know Before Your First Appointment

Can I Use Insurance for Therapy? graphic with an insurance card and therapy illustrations

One of the most common questions I hear from prospective patients is:

“Will my insurance cover therapy?”

The honest answer is: it depends on your individual insurance plan.

As the Training and Development Manager at Dr. Goldberg & Associates, I spend a significant amount of time helping patients understand their mental health benefits. Insurance can be confusing, and many people delay getting help simply because they are unsure what their financial responsibility will be.

The good news is that many of these concerns can be answered with a simple phone call. Before assuming therapy, medication management, or psychological testing is too expensive, I always encourage patients to verify their benefits. You may be pleasantly surprised by what your insurance covers.

The Biggest Misconception About Insurance and Therapy

One of the biggest misconceptions I see is that people assume their insurance will not cover mental health services.

Sometimes that’s true. Many times, it isn’t.

Insurance coverage depends on many different factors, including:

  • Your specific insurance plan
  • Whether your provider is in-network
  • Your deductible
  • Your copay or coinsurance
  • The diagnosis being treated
  • The billing codes used for your services

Even plans offered through the same insurance company can have very different benefits.

I experienced this myself when I was searching for a therapist. I found a provider listed as accepting Blue Cross Blue Shield, but when I called to schedule, I learned they only accepted BCBS PPO plans—not my BCBS HMO plan.

That experience reinforced an important lesson: never assume coverage based solely on the insurance company name. Always verify your specific plan.

Don’t Let Assumptions Delay Your Care

I recently spoke with a friend who wanted psychological testing for ADHD, autism, and OCD. She had heard about someone else receiving a large bill from another practice and assumed testing would be unaffordable.

Before she decided against scheduling, I encouraged her to verify her benefits.

We reviewed her insurance information and discussed what the testing process would look like. I explained that psychological testing is typically completed over four to five billed appointments rather than one enormous visit, which helped her better understand how claims would be submitted.

After verifying her benefits, we discovered something she wasn’t expecting.

Her deductible did not apply to psychological testing.

Instead, she would only be responsible for approximately $120 to $150 in copays for the entire testing process.

She is now moving forward with scheduling her evaluation.

Had she relied on assumptions, she might have delayed getting answers that could significantly improve her quality of life.

Every Insurance Plan Is Different

One of the most important things I tell patients is that every insurance plan works differently.

Two people with the same insurance company may have completely different coverage because they have different plans through their employer or marketplace.

Your insurance company can tell you things like:

  • Whether your deductible applies
  • Your copay or coinsurance amount
  • Whether your provider is in-network
  • Whether prior authorization is required
  • Whether telehealth is covered
  • Whether there are limits on the number of visits each year

Your provider’s office can often estimate your benefits, but your insurance company is always the best source for information about your specific plan.

What to Ask Your Insurance Company

When you call your insurance company, don’t simply ask:

“Do you cover therapy?”

That question often produces vague answers.

Instead, ask about the specific CPT codes your provider uses.

For example, at our practice we commonly use the following codes.

Therapy

  • 90791
  • 90837

Psychological Testing

  • 96130
  • 96131
  • 96132
  • 96133
  • 96136
  • 96137

Medication Management

  • 90792
  • 99205
  • 99213
  • 99214
  • 99215
  • 90833

Every practice bills differently, so if you are unsure which CPT codes apply to your services, ask your provider before calling your insurance company.

You should also ask:

  • Does my deductible apply?
  • What is my copay or coinsurance?
  • Are telehealth appointments covered?
  • Are both in-person and virtual visits covered equally?
  • Do I need prior authorization?
  • Are there limits on the number of covered visits each year?

Having these answers before your first appointment can help eliminate many unexpected surprises.

Why I Still Recommend Calling Your Insurance Company Yourself

At Dr. Goldberg & Associates, we verify benefits whenever possible.

However, I still recommend that patients contact their insurance company directly.

Insurance companies are much more likely to provide detailed information directly to their members than they are to a healthcare office.

Our benefit estimates are based on the information available through insurance portals, but sometimes that information is incomplete. Claims can also process differently because of internal insurance rules that providers don’t always have access to.

That is why I encourage patients to become active participants in understanding their own benefits.

Always Document Your Phone Calls

Whenever you speak with your insurance company, write down:

  • The representative’s name
  • The date
  • The time
  • The reference number for the call

If a claim is later processed differently than what you were told, having documentation of your conversation can be incredibly helpful when appealing the decision.

Your First Claim Often Provides the Best Answers

One thing many patients don’t realize is that the first processed insurance claim often gives us the clearest picture of future costs.

At our practice, we generally submit the first claim, wait for the insurance company to process it, and then contact the patient with:

  • Their current balance
  • Their patient responsibility
  • What future sessions are expected to cost based on how the claim processed

This allows us to provide much more accurate financial information moving forward.

Advocate for Yourself

Insurance companies increasingly rely on automated claims processing systems, and mistakes do happen.

If something doesn’t seem right, ask questions.

If your explanation of benefits doesn’t match what you were told, contact both your insurance company and your provider’s billing department.

Sometimes claims are processed incorrectly as out-of-network or denied for reasons that can be corrected.

If something feels wrong, it is worth investigating.

Should You Wait Until You’ve Met Your Deductible?

Many people postpone therapy because they haven’t met their deductible yet.

I completely understand that concern.

However, I also encourage patients to ask themselves one important question:

Do I need help now?

Waiting several months to begin treatment may delay progress toward your personal, emotional, or relationship goals.

If finances are a concern, talk with your provider.

There may be options such as:

  • Payment plans
  • Adjusting session frequency
  • Scheduling every other week instead of weekly
  • Exploring other services that better fit your budget

Open communication often creates more options than patients realize.

Think Ahead During Open Enrollment

If therapy, medication management, or psychological testing is something you anticipate needing, it may be worth comparing insurance plans during your employer’s open enrollment period.

Some plans have:

  • Lower deductibles
  • Better mental health coverage
  • Lower copays
  • More in-network providers

Your HR department can often help explain your available options so you can choose a plan that better supports both your healthcare needs and your financial goals.

Don’t Forget to Update Your Insurance

One of the most difficult conversations I have with patients happens when someone changes insurance but forgets to notify our office.

They may attend several appointments before we discover that their old insurance is no longer active.

Sometimes their new insurance is out-of-network, creating unexpected expenses that could have been avoided.

Any time you receive a new insurance card—even if you still have the same insurance company—notify all of your healthcare providers before your next appointment.

Family and Couples Therapy May Be Covered Too

Many people assume family or couples therapy is never covered by insurance because some practices only offer these services as private pay.

In reality, many insurance plans do cover family or couples therapy, often billed under CPT code 90847.

Coverage frequently depends on medical necessity and whether the service is billed with a covered mental health diagnosis (an F-code) rather than a non-medical Z-code.

This is another great example of why it’s always worth checking your individual benefits instead of assuming you will have to pay out of pocket.

Insurance Doesn’t Have to Be Overwhelming

Insurance is designed to help make healthcare more accessible and affordable, even though navigating benefits can sometimes feel overwhelming.

Taking the first step to understand your coverage can make the next step much easier.

When you call your insurance company, they can explain your benefits and provide a list of in-network providers. Your provider’s billing team can also help answer questions about claims and patient responsibility.

At Dr. Goldberg & Associates, we want patients to feel informed and confident before beginning care. While we may sometimes refer you to your insurance company for the most accurate information, that is because we want you to receive the most complete answers possible.

If therapy isn’t financially feasible today, don’t give up.

Take time to explore your insurance options during your next open enrollment period, discuss plan choices with your HR department, and continue planning for your mental health goals.

Most importantly, don’t let assumptions keep you from getting the help you deserve.

As the saying goes:

“You miss 100 percent of the shots you don’t take.”

Sometimes one phone call is all it takes to discover that getting the support you need is much more affordable than you imagined.

Ready to start therapy, medication management, or testing?

Dr. Goldberg & Associates is in-network with Anthem, Blue Cross Blue Shield, CIGNA, and United Healthcare. Reach out today.

Written by:

Moriah Veer

Training & Development Manager

Dr. Goldberg & Associates